If like me you are a) Fed up of all these different diets
that we should be following or b) Confused at what is now considered good or
bad foods; then you should definitely have a read of Diet Cults by Matt
Fitzgerald.
Matt is an endurance sports writer, coach, nutritionist, and
athlete so he knows his stuff. In fact I have read a lot of Matt's articles
over the years on the Internet and always find his work, knowledgeable,
accurate and mostly common sense!
Once you've read the book and considered all the main diet
cults that are out there it does make you question how can one diet be the
correct diet, how can one diet allow grains and another not. Its similar to
religion, whose right because not everyone can be.
Matt almost sums it up in one example; with the odd
exceptions, no elite athlete follows any of these diet cults but rather follows what
science teaches us after years and years of practice of what is right. Now what does that tell you straight away.
"We saw, through the example of Paleo dieters, that
people don’t choose diets by reason; rather, diets choose people by appealing
to identity-based dispositions such as masculine self-image."
The Paleo diet is probably one of the most popular diets around today, but Matt refers to archeological evidence that "with new methods of extracting DNA from dental plaque revealed both Neanderthals and Paleolithic people ate barley, beans and tubers". Hominids living two and a half million years ago ate more grasses and grains than fruit and leaves and "that virtually every food humans eat today is different from those eaten by our Paleolithic ancestors"....and people are making money and living their lives based on diet that doesn't and has never existed!
All these various diets miss out on key nutrients between them and there is not a
'bad' nutrient out there, even sugar which has had more bad press than normal
in recent years, if used correctly has a benefit ie. for sport and energy. It's
when it gets abused by people consuming it in processed foods like sweets and
cakes that it becomes a problem.
Energy drinks are loaded with sugars and have a place if
you're running a marathon but not guzzled daily by kids as a 'cool' drink and
that's where sports drinks manufacturers are to be held responsible. They are
quite happy for it to be sold in newsagents, supermarkets and vending machines
the world round knowing full well that people are consuming them as a soft
drink and not what they were intended for!....OK I digress, back to the book!
Gluten intolerance is on the rise or is it? As Matt experienced with his own Mother, stress can cause similar symptoms and the world we live in is becoming increasingly stressful affecting more and more people in many ways.
You dont have to be a nutritionist to understand the book,
the author's writing does not leave you baffled with scientific spill but an
understanding of ...well how basically, when you put all these diets next to
each other how bizarre they really sound.
To sum up these chapters, it is that there is no such thing as one true way to eat for health.
In the last chapter of the book Matt explains his own way of Agnostic healthy eating. By no means is this the author hitting on us with another diet cult but putting all foods into a diet quality hierarchy. Ten categories of foods to eat in order of quality, sticking mainly to the foods at the top of the list but not ruling out anything. The order is as you would expect: vegetables,fruits,nuts&seeds,high quality meat and seafood,whole grains,dairy,refined grains,low quality meat and seafood,sweets,fried foods. The lower you go down the list the less you eat of, in other words, a healthy balanced diet.
It sounds simple, but with all these diet cults existing, it's getting harder to see the wood for the trees.
